Why In the Dark Merch Fits Everyone
When I first started designing merch, I saw fans of all shapes and sizes struggling to find gear that felt like it was made for them. The In the Dark plus size collection was built to fix that - not as an afterthought, but as a core part of the lineup. This guide covers everything you need to know about finding your perfect fit in 2026, from sizing charts to fan-favorite items.
A Collection for Every Body
The In the Dark brand has always celebrated individuality, and that extends to apparel. The plus size range includes sizes up to 5XL in most styles, with careful attention to fit across different body types. Whether you're looking for a relaxed hoodie or a fitted tee, there's an option designed to feel comfortable and look sharp.
Available Plus Size Options in the Store
T-Shirts
The everyday tee comes in sizes S-5XL, made from 100% ring-spun cotton (180 gsm). I love the way the fabric holds its shape after multiple washes - no shrinking or twisting. The graphic prints use a soft-hand screen process that won't crack or peel, even on larger sizes where the print covers more area.
Hoodies
For cooler days, the pullover hoodie is the top seller in plus sizes. It's a 50/50 cotton-polyester blend (280 gsm) that's warm without being heavy. The hood is double-lined, and the drawstrings are thick enough to tie without slipping. Sizes go up to 3XL in most colorways, with extended options up to 5XL in black and gray.
Tank Tops and Long Sleeves
Tank tops (S-4XL) are perfect for layering or warmer weather. They feature wider armholes and a longer length to avoid riding up. Long sleeves (S-5XL) use the same cotton-poly blend as the hoodies, with ribbed cuffs that stay snug.
How to Choose the Right Size for You
Step 1: Take Your Measurements
Use a soft tape measure and follow these steps:
- Chest: Measure around the fullest part, keeping the tape horizontal. Add 2-4 inches for a relaxed fit.
- Waist: Measure at your natural waistline (above the belly button).
- Hips: Measure at the widest point.
- Length: For tops, measure from the top of your shoulder to where you want the hem to hit.
Step 2: Compare to the Size Chart
Every product page has a detailed size chart. For example, a 2XL tee fits a 48-50 inch chest and 44-46 inch waist. Don't rely on your usual size from other brands - In the Dark's sizing runs slightly larger for a relaxed silhouette. I've found that if you're between sizes, going down gives a more fitted look while going up offers a baggy streetwear vibe.
Step 3: Consider the Fabric
Cotton-poly blends (hoodies, long sleeves) have less stretch than tri-blends or cotton-spandex. If you prefer a snug fit in a hoodie, stick to your chest measurement. For tees, 100% cotton will soften and relax after a few washes, so a closer fit at purchase will become ideal over time.
Top Rated Plus Size Items from Fans
I reached out to the In the Dark community and asked for their favorites. Here are the top-rated picks:
- "Shadow" Graphic Tee (Plus): Rated 4.7/5 stars. Fans love the oversized cut and the bold print that doesn't shrink. One fan said, "I've washed this 20 times and it still looks brand new."
- "Nightfall" Pullover Hoodie (Plus): 4.8/5 stars. The fleece lining is soft and doesn't pill. Multiple reviews mention the pockets are deep enough for a phone and keys.
- "Eclipse" Tank Top (Plus): 4.5/5 stars. Great for layering under flannels or wearing alone. The armholes are cut higher to avoid showing bra straps.
Pro tip from the community: If you're between sizes in the hoodie, go up for extra coziness - the polyester blend keeps it from feeling bulky.
Care Tips for Your Plus Size Gear
Washing
Turn all graphic items inside out before washing. Use cold water and a gentle cycle. This preserves the print and prevents fading. Avoid fabric softeners - they break down the cotton fibers over time.
Drying
Air dry whenever possible. If you use a dryer, set it to low heat and remove the item while it's still slightly damp. Hanging dry hoodies can stretch them out, so lay them flat on a drying rack.
Storing
Fold heavy items like hoodies to avoid stretching the shoulders on hangers. Tees can be hung or folded, but if you hang them, use padded hangers to prevent shoulder bumps.
Common Mistake: Overwashing
You don't need to wash after every wear. Spot clean small stains and wash every 3-5 wears to extend the life of your gear. This is especially important for plus sizes - the fabric needs less friction to stay strong.
Pro Tips from the Community
I asked veteran fans for their insider tricks:
- Tip 1: Layer smart. The tank top under an oversized flannel is a popular combo. The tank's length ensures it won't untuck.
- Tip 2: Pre-shrink with care. If you prefer a snugger fit, wash a new tee in warm water once and air dry. This minimizes future shrinkage.
- Tip 3: Watch the print placement. On larger sizes, prints are scaled proportionally. Check the product photos to see where the design falls on the chest or back.
- Tip 4: Seasonal switches. The hoodie is great for fall, but the tee works year-round. I always recommend the tee as a first purchase because it's the most versatile.
Recommended Gear & Products
If you're new to In the Dark plus size, start with the "Shadow" Graphic Tee. It's the most reviewed item in extended sizes, with a classic fit that pairs with anything. For cooler weather, the "Nightfall" Hoodie is worth the investment - the cotton-poly blend breathes well even when layering. Both items are available up to 5XL in the most popular colors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What sizes are available in In the Dark plus size?
Most tees go up to 5XL, hoodies up to 3XL (5XL in select colors), and tank tops to 4XL. Check individual product pages for specific size ranges.
How does the sizing compare to standard US sizes?
In the Dark sizing runs slightly larger than typical US brands. For example, a 2XL fits like a standard 2XL but with more room in the chest and shoulders. Always consult the size chart on the product page.
Are there any new plus size items coming in 2026?
The store updates seasonally. In late 2026, look for a new line of plus size zip-up hoodies and joggers. Keep an eye on the newsletter for announcements.
Do the prints fade over time?
With proper care (inside-out wash, cold water, low heat), the screen-printed graphics stay vibrant for dozens of washes. The plus size prints are designed with extra ink coverage to prevent cracking.
What is the best selling plus size item?
The "Nightfall" Pullover Hoodie is the most popular, followed closely by the "Shadow" Graphic Tee. Both have over 500 reviews with an average rating of 4.7 stars.
Key Takeaways
- In the Dark plus size includes tees, hoodies, tank tops, and long sleeves up to 5XL.
- Take your measurements and compare to the size chart for the best fit.
- The "Nightfall" Hoodie and "Shadow" Tee are fan favorites with proven durability.
- Care tips: wash inside out on cold, air dry, and don't overwash.
- The community recommends starting with the tee for versatility.
